Sharing Is Not A Virtue
November 19, 2013  |  parenting

Whether at the park, the mall, or on a play date with my children, I frequently hear parents commanding their kids, “You need to share!” Or, they go out of their way to praise their child when they do share, “You shared your toy so well!”

Other parents, such as myself, who follow Magda Gerber’s RIE parenting philosophy, buy into the idea that sharing should never be forced. The reason is that sharing is, by its very nature, a voluntary activity. When you force your child to share, what you are doing is much closer to an act of theft than an act of sharing. The child learns he has to give up his valued possessions because somebody else wants him to. That puts him on the defensive by default, so it’s no wonder he doesn’t like the idea of “sharing.”

RIE also recognizes that if a child chooses to share, it should be an authentic expression of his wishes, so we don’t want to unduly influence or encourage sharing, either. It should happen naturally.

Still, I’ve seen even the most dedicated RIE parents secretly celebrating when their child shares with another, or complimenting another parent for how well their children share. Ironically, it is true that when children are not forced to share, they end up sharing more openly and freely with others.  Some RIE parents are attracted to RIE because of this very fact. After all, isn’t sharing more openly and freely good?

However, sharing is not a virtue — nor is it a vice. The concept of sharing means choosing to let someone else use something you have or that is yours. It is a morally neutral concept.

When it comes to values and moral values, the important factor in an act of sharing is with whom you share and why you share it. Should your daughter share her toys with her friends so they can play together? What about a bully at school to win his approval?  I trust most parents who would rush to praise the sharing of toys between friends find it hard to tell their child, “You shared your homework with the class bully again! You’re such a good sharer!”

Sharing is really about the personal connection and exchange of values (spiritual or otherwise) between two individuals. That is not something that can be forced or taught. If I want to share something with you, it’s because I want to share it with you. And it’s because I want to share it with YOU (yes, you specifically, not someone else). It is not because I want to “just share it.” This paradigm shift helps us better understand and identify what is actually happening when our children do share.

As parents, what does this mean in practice?  Instead of recognizing the act of sharing itself , we should be focusing on the actual values our children are sharing. Examples: Instead of , “You shared your truck!,” try, “I see you wanted to let Susie play with your truck.” Instead of, “You don’t want to share your water,” try, “You’re drinking all the water, you must be thirsty.” Instead of, “You shared your stuffed bear with Suzie,” try, “You handed Suzie the bear because you’re curious how she will play with it.”

How do you know if you’re focusing on the values and not sharing as such?  Try to observe what is happening without using the S-word. That will usually force your mind to see the values and not the sharing (or lack of sharing, e.g., “Sally wanted to take the truck, but you wanted to keep playing with it”).

With this approach, even the act of not sharing is transformed from something seemingly negative into a positive, value-recognizing opportunity (“Johnny wants the balls but Jack is really focused on working with them right now”). This will help you identify what both parties want, which is crucial to problem solving should there be a conflict over “sharing” something in particular.

Still, as parents, it can be hard to break the desire for our kids to share.  It just feels nice, doesn’t it? But when we put, even if only secretly in our own minds, some kind of expectation of what the child *should* do, they pick up on it.

RIE parents want their children children to act authentically and their choices to come internally from within themselves, not others (including their parents). Our reactions should be no different, whether a child chooses to share something or not.

Instead, we should simply be recognizing their value choices. Example: “Oh yes, I see you wanted her to go on the ride next because she was upset.” Or, on the opposite end, “Oh yes, I see you really wanted to go on the ride, you were waiting a long time for it.”

In this example, we should have no more — or less — pride in our child valuing to get on the ride than her offering it to her friend. Our pride, as parents, should be reserved for the fact that our children are making their own value judgments and their choices are coming from within, i.e., are authentic.

Our goal should not be to produce sharing children, but rather to foster authentic children who are respected and, incidentally, happen to share pretty well. Contrast this with a forced (or even highly encouraged) sharing approach: from the child’s perspective, it’s the difference between having one’s values recognized or having them taken away.

Most important, when a child shares, or chooses not to share, it is an expression of his inner-most wants, desires, and chosen values. Let’s focus on those values — and celebrate them.

  • Julie – Ladybug’s Spots

    Great post, we had an ‘incident’ this morning which made me question my stance on the whole sharing thing and your post really resonates with me and how I felt about it all!